Apple AirTags vs Tile tracker
This article is part of our series Battle of the Brands, in which we compare category-leading products to their counterparts to determine which are actually worth your money.
In the realm of item tracking, Tile is likely the most well-known Bluetooth tracker. With a plethora of models to choose from and compatibility across devices, Tile has made it easy to locate items at various price points. Now Apple is in the item-tracking game with the $29 AirTag — and features like Precision Finding and Apple integration make it competitive against Tile.
Both use Bluetooth for tracking and connect to a network of other devices, which work to pinpoint locations. Tile has a network made up of millions of devices, while Apple uses its far-reaching Find My network, approaching a billion devices. Neither feature GPS and rely on the connected devices to assign that location as the Bluetooth signal is picked up.
The core difference is the size of each respective network, and it gives a reason for Tile to have some concern. Let’s break down the biggest pros and cons of each tracker.
Apple Airtag
You should get an AirTag if you have an iPhone and want an item tracker. AirTag integrates directly into Find My and is simple to use. Those with an iPhone 11 or newer will get to take advantage of Precision Finding as well.
$29 at Apple
$29 at Amazon
Tile Tracker
Those who primarily use Android (or who prefer an agnostic OS approach) should opt for a Tile. You get to pick from four designs and will appreciate the built-in functionality. And while the network is smaller, it’s still an accurate way to track items.
$25 at Tile
$25 at Amazon
Apple AirTag |
Tile Mate |
|
---|---|---|
Compatibility |
iOS |
iOS, Android |
1.name”>Size and weight |
1.26 x 1.26 inches, 0.39 ounces |
1.48 x 1.48 x 0.27 inches, 0.28 ounces |
Built-in key ring |
No |
Yes |
Precision Finding |
Yes |
No |
Price |
$29 |
$25 |
Jacob Krol/CNN
cnn.com/_components/paragraph/instances/paragraph_FA1CEDA0-1F80-2172-1878-3E3F1439AEBA@published” data-editable=”text” data-component-name=”paragraph”>It pays to go with AirTag if you have an iPhone. The setup happens in just under a minute, and no heavy lifting is required. You also don’t need to make an account since the tracker is tied directly to your Apple ID. The whole experience lives within the Find My app, making it easy to see your AirTag and other devices that support Find My. It’s the same way you’d track a Mac, Apple Watch, iPad or even AirPods. The experience is straightforward and intuitive.
Within the Find My app, you tap the Items tab to see all of your AirTags on a map and easily ping them. It’s all built in to the point that you can even ask Siri where one is or create a shortcut to access it easily. With Tile, you’ll need to open the Tile app, and it’s just a bit more clunky. And with standard tracking on a map, AirTags have tended to be more accurate than a Tile tracker. Apple’s network is made up of all the iPhones, iPads, Macs and iPod Touches online — that total number is approaching a billion. It’s a more extensive network over Tile’s, which is in the millions.
If you have an iPhone 11 or newer, you’ll get to use Precision Finding with AirTag. Essentially, when you’re looking for an AirTag and you have a general idea of where it is, you can click Find in the app for the respective tag and get turn-by-turn directions to it. Distance away in feet and arrows on the screen will help guide you to the tracker, and it all updates in real time.
Precision Finding is made possible by Apple’s U1 Chip, which delivers ultra-wideband support. The newer iPhones listed above support this and can use it to see where the devices are, spatially. It also uses a range of other tech (ARKit, Bluetooth and sensors) to enable this feature. It’s something that Tile cannot match yet, as it doesn’t feature ultra-wideband.
There is only one AirTag to pick from, and its design functionality is a bit limited. It’s a small circular disc that features no adhesive padding or even a key ring hole. Luckily, it does feature a user-replaceable battery that should last for a year. You will need to purchase an accessory, like a key ring for $35 from Apple or $12.95 from Belkin, to secure it onto something.
Jacob Krol/CNN
If you’re looking for broad compatibility, Tile is the winner with Android, iOS and Windows support. Some devices like headphones and laptops even come with Tile tracking built in out of the box. Setup is done through the Tile app and requires Bluetooth pairing. It’s easy enough but not integrated on the base software level like AirTags.
Regardless of which Tile you choose, you’ll have an easy way to attach it to something out of the box. That’s something that the AirTag can’t match and requires you to purchase an accessory. And Tile offers a few models, which, while confusing, does give you more choice. You also get the advantage of pushing a button on a Tile to ring your connected device. It’s pretty handy and has helped us find our phone.
Tile Sticker
This is the smallest Tile and is a black circle with a way to attach out of the box. You can use the adhesive back side. It features a standard Bluetooth range, and the battery cannot be replaced.
$25 at Amazon
From $30 at Tile
Tile Slim
The Slim fits perfectly into a wallet, with a design that mimics two stacked credit cards. Like the Sticker, the battery cannot be replaced and you’ll need to buy a new tracker when the battery runs dry.
$30
$28 at Amazon
From $35 at Tile
Tile Mate
The original Tile is now the Mate, and it features a user-replaceable battery. It keeps the classic square design that is splash-resistant against water and has a built-in key ring hole.
$25 at Amazon
$25 at Tile
Tile Pro
Tile Pro builds off the Mate with a rugged build and long-range Bluetooth. It sports a user-replaceable battery and a key ring hole. Additionally, the speaker inside can produce a louder tone, which is helpful for finding.
$35
$26 at Amazon
From $35 at Tile
And like AirTag (and Samsung’s SmartTag or Chipolo), the same basic technology for tracking is Bluetooth. Essentially, the tracker can connect with other devices on Tile’s network, which works to pinpoint a location to your tracker. The key issue is that Tile’s network is much smaller and relies on Tile devices or those with the app. It’s in the millions, while Apple’s is approaching a billion.
You’ll still be able to spot your tracker on a map, though, and you can even set alerts if you’re on Tile Premium. The latter is a subscription service (starting at $30 per year) that can deliver smart alerts if you leave something behind as well as make your Tile eligible for a battery replacement. It’s not really a requirement and doesn’t boost the network in a way that levels the playing field against AirTag, however.
The core promises of the AirTag and Tile trackers are pretty much the same. You’ll be able to locate each tracker on a map with relative ease via your smartphone. Tile wins in the design category, with multiple models to pick from that feature a way to attach out of the box. And if you’re on a device besides an iPhone, Tile is the obvious choice since AirTag doesn’t support anything besides Apple.
But if you have an iPhone, the answer is to get an AirTag. The integration makes setup a breeze, and all controls are found in the Find My app. You can even ask Siri on an iPhone or HomePod Mini to find the tracker. The Find My network covers more territory and is more accurate in our testing for item finding. That trend continues with more congruent tracking through Precision Finding if you have a newer iPhone. You will need to pair your $29 AirTag with an accessory, though.
Track Your Family, Friends, Keys, Wallets, and More
All in one place
Call off the search party.
Because everything (and everyone) is in one place — your Life360 map. When you link your Life360 and Tile accounts, your whole Circle can see your Tiles and quickly find lost items.
Find it all
Ring your Tiles through the Life360 app.
Keys in the couch cushions? Wallet in the… fridge? Really? Use your phone to ring nearby Tiles — and use your Tiles to ring your phone, even if it’s on silent.
Bluetooth signal
Work the network.
All Tiles emit a secure Bluetooth signal. So when a phone with the Tile app passes by your lost item, you’ll get a location update — automatically and anonymously.
Dark purple arrow pointing up
Save up to 44% by switching to annual plans.
MEMBERSHIP BENEFITS
- 2 days Location History
- 2 places with Unlimited Alert
- Family Driving Summary
- SOS Help Alert
Most popular
Includes Tile Mate*
A $25 VALUE
MEMBERSHIP BENEFITS
- 30 days Location History
- Unlimited Place Alerts
- $25K Stolen Funds Reimbursement
- $250 Stolen Phone Protection
Includes Tile Starter Pack*
A $55 VALUE
MEMBERSHIP BENEFITS
- 30 days Location History
- 50 miles Free towing
- $1M Stolen Funds Reimbursement
- $500 Stolen Phone Protection
Tile Mate
Attach Mate to everyday things like keys and bags, and use our free app to find them. Keep track of more for less with our multi-packs or give them to your friends and family as a gift.
Up to 250 ft / 76 m Bluetooth range
Up to 3-year non-replaceable battery
Water resistant
Works with Android™ and Apple® devices
Voice-assisted finding with Alexa, Google and Siri
Tile Starter Pack
A selection of Tiles to help keep track of many different things. Keep track of more for less with our multi-packs or give them to your friends and family as a gift.
Up to 250 ft / 76 m Bluetooth range
Up to 3-year non-replaceable battery
Water resistant
Works with Android™ and Apple® devices
Voice-assisted finding with Alexa, Google and Siri
Privacy and security
Your trust comes first.
A big part of that is doing the right thing when no one’s watching. That means maintaining our commitment to investing in features that enhance your customer experience while staying focused on your privacy and security. That includes features like Scan and Secure that allows you to easily scan and detect unknown Tiles that may be traveling with you.
Learn more
Get started right here, right now.
See everyone and everything you love in one place — in just a few steps.
1
Not a Life360 member? Get the app!
2
Activate your Tiles in the Tile app
3
Link your Life360 and Tile accounts in the Life360 app
4
See your Tiles on your Life360 map
Get a free Tile with a Life360 premium membership. Limited time only.
Pick your plan
*One time offer per user for both monthly and annual memberships. See full Terms & Conditions.
Tile tracker adds a new undetectable mode, claims to help victims of stalking
Launched a new Anti-Theft mode for Tile trackers that completely prevents them from being detected by anyone other than the user if the owner has registered a photo ID in companies.
All of the recent attention to the capabilities of small tracking devices has come from Apple’s launch of their AirTags and all the built-in anti-surveillance features. However, in the security dispute, longtime tracking company Tile announced that it would be adding some anti-harassment measures.
A year later, these small initial measures were added to, and Tile at the same time also stated that Apple’s security measures actually reduced the effectiveness of the use of trackers for security.
“Unlike other Bluetooth trackers on the market, namely AirTags,” the company said in a press release, “Tile does not notify nearby smartphone users when an unknown Bluetooth tracker travels with them.”
“Some competitor products go so far as to beep as soon as the tracker is separated from its owner,” he continues, “letting it know that the tracker is present and allowing thieves to pinpoint it.”
New anti-theft mode
This horn requires a speaker in the device, and whether Tile should have had this feature before or not, it cannot now retroactively add it to the millions of existing devices.
So Tile’s initial response to the stalking controversy was to create an app called Scan and Secure, which allowed iPhone and Android users to scan nearby Tile trackers – as soon as they suspected they were present.
However, the new release of Tile adds an additional anti-theft mode that specifically prevents something from being detected by the same application.
“This is achieved by keeping Tile Bluetooth trackers running in anti-theft mode from being detected by scanning and protection,” the press release says. Tile users can enable Anti-Theft on any Tile tracker they use, including Tile-enabled partner products.”
Tile CEO Chris Hulls argues on his blog that there are reasons the company is “taking a different approach.”
“When news of the risks of harassment associated with the use of Bluetooth trackers exploded,” writes Tile, “Tile immediately took action to create protection for consumers, even those who are not our customers.”
Describing the “well-intentioned but hasty changes made by Apple, us at Tile and others”, he claims that “current anti-retaliation features barely work. ”
“In order to better deter harassment, we need to increase the likelihood that stalkers get caught and then greatly increase the consequences when they are caught,” says Hulls. “Today, the punishment for stalking is often a slap in the face.”
Tile solves the stalking problem
By default, Tile trackers remain discoverable by Scan and Secure. If someone wants to enable the new Anti-Theft mode, they must:
Provide government-issued ID to verify your identity. Allow Tile to share data with law enforcement. Agree to pay $1 million if they are later found guilty of stalking using Tile devices.
The tile does not indicate who will receive the $1 million. While this “significantly increases the consequences” for the stalker, it’s less clear how it increases the likelihood of being caught in any way.
Presumably they are supposed to be traceable via this government ID, just like Apple can trace AirTags back to their owners. However, this only works at best when the victim physically discovers the tile.
Even in this case, it is unclear whether the victim can do anything. It appears that Thile’s efforts are focused on fining the stalker as soon as everyone else, from the victim through law enforcement and the courts, finds them.
Hulls also undermines the apparent benefit of being able to hide Tile devices from Tile’s own scanning and protection feature, saying the firm is “shocked” at how little it is used.
“Out of our millions of active Tile users, we see this feature being used an average of 52 times per day across our entire iOS and Android user base – that’s not a typo!” He says.
However, this suggests that users are either unaware of this feature or have no reason at all to suspect they are being tracked.
The new Tile Anti-Theft Mode has begun rolling out to users and should be available to all customers within a few weeks.
Tags:
iOSiPhone
Ampere Vent Glace → Pomeranian
Amper Vent Gleys
Edit →
Editing on our site is available only to registered users.
You must
to come in
or
get registered.
KOI:  | 0.98% |
Color:  | Orange sable |
Gender:  | male |
Age:  | 4 years |
Born:  | October 8, 2018 |
Breeder:  | Balashova Ekaterina (Ryazan) |
Pedigree
Show/hide photo
3
4
5
6
Ch. Tsvetomir Manly Iz Laguna Grez × RKF 4455622 PL-00 |
Luxury Marseille 38074.. |
Ch.RKF, Ch.RUS Starpom Luxury × RKF3592614 |
Ch.RKF, Ch.RUS, Ch.CAN, Ch.USA Island’s Hanging With The Band × RKF3033000 AKC TR65580601 |
Ch.RUS, Ch.CAN, Ch.USA Cr Classic Act × AKCTR49660004 |
Ch.USA Cheyennes Kodiak Bear Second × AKC TP09565801 Eyes clear, LCP clear, hips excellent |
Geebears Cr Carebear AKC TR16074106 Eyes clear, hips good |
|||||
Ch. Pominique Flecks Of Gold × AKCTR218 |
Ch.RKF, Ch.RUS, Ch.USA PJ’s Sir Richard Of Goldchip × AKC TR02232302 RKF1920226 |
||||
Pominique Black Hills Gold AKC TP27560201 |
|||||
Starpom Narayada RKF 2558706 |
Ch.RKF, Ch.RUS, Ch.USA PJ’s Sir Richard Of Goldchip × AKC TR02232302 RKF1920226 |
PJ’s What a Guy AKC TN27854602 |
|||
Ch.USA PJ’s Agatha × AKC TN55762001 |
|||||
Zanga RKF 17 |
Ch.RKF, Ch.OANKOO, Ch.RUS Aljens Lil Gangsta of Lenette × RKF1671485 AKC TR 24330301 |
||||
Invita RKF 1347921 |
|||||
Golden Mandarin Mirabella May |
Ch. Tatiana’s Lil Southpaw Man × RKF1622802 AKC TR08234301 |
Southpaws Jokers Wild AKC 66694601 |
Ch.USA Mo Beta Star Stopper × AKC TN16937403 |
||
Tim Sue’s Luck Be A Lady AKC TM94423401 |
|||||
Nashobas Crystal N Bronzeboots AKC 05838202 |
Ch.USA, Ch.CAN Chriscendo Classico × CKC EA256756 AKC28431001 |
||||
Fantasy Moonlite Crystals AKC TN 46827401 |
|||||
Aphrodite Aurika RKF 2512491 |
JCh.RUS, Ch.RUS Beautiful Star’s D-Lion × RKF1920310 THKCE06110919 |
K. |
|||
Pleng’s Rackoon |
|||||
Tequila RKF 2184797 |
Almi Yurnis Midnight Star RKF1787178 |
||||
Vestal |
|||||
Hailey Fairy Tile from the Lagoon of Dreams 3610481 |
Grand Ch.RUS, JCh.RUS, Ch.CLUB, Ch.RKF, Ch.RUS Almi Yournis Richard Lion’s Hut × RKF2258250 |
Ch.RUS, Ch.UZB Tatiana’s Lil Southpaw Man × RKF1622802 AKC TR08234301 |
Southpaws Jokers Wild AKC 66694601 |
Ch.USA Mo Beta Star Stopper × AKC TN16937403 |
|
Tim Sue’s Luck Be A Lady AKC TM94423401 |
|||||
Nashobas Crystal N Bronzeboots AKC 05838202 |
Ch. Chriscendo Classico × CKC EA256756 AKC28431001 |
||||
Fantasy Moonlite Crystals AKC TN 46827401 |
|||||
JCh.RUS, JCh.CLUB, Ch.OANKOO, Ch.RUS Almi Yurnis Princes Of Moonlight × RKF 1836195 |
Grand Ch.RUS, Ch.CLUB, Ch.RUS Jan-Shar’s Harry Potter × RKF1339418 AKC19781403 |
Ch.USA Jan Shar’s Head Over Heels × AKC 28143901 |
|||
Ch.USA Jan-Shar’s Zsa Zsa × AKC 46386001 |
|||||
Jan Shar’s Sweet Tart RKF1511576 AKC TP32233002 |
Ch.USA Jan Shars N Sync × AKS TR02953204 |
||||
Britestar’s Crm Miracle |
|||||
Dilina Royal Sparks Of Champagne RKF2599674 EST03025/09 |
Ch.INT, EUW, ESTW, Ch.SWE, Ch.FIN, Ch.EST, Ch.LVA, Ch.LTU, Ch.BALT, JCh.EST Almi Yurnis Vermont × RKF1532793 EST01495/05 |
Grand Ch.RUS, Ch.CLUB, Ch.RUS Jan-Shar’s Harry Potter × RKF1339418 AKC19781403 |
Ch.USA Jan Shar’s Head Over Heels × AKC 28143901 |
||
Ch.USA Jan-Shar’s Zsa Zsa × AKC 46386001 |
|||||
Jan Shar’s Sweet Tart RKF1511576 AKC TP32233002 |
Ch.USA Jan Shars N Sync × AKS TR02953204 |
||||
Britestar’s Crm Miracle |
|||||
JCh.EST Dilina Royal Margaret De Claire × EST 03435/07 |
JCh. Jolly Dwarf Nocturne × RKF 1926173 PL1/1 |
Ch.RFLS, Ch.RUS, Ch.CAN Damascus Road Dream Of Tucson × RKF17 CKC PG944932 |
|||
JCh.RUS, Ch.RUS Jolly Gnome Blues Rhapsody × RKF 1671682 |
|||||
ESTW, Ch.EST, JCh.EST Dilina Royal Mona Lisa × EST 027023/05 |
Ch.INT, EUW, ESTW, Ch.SWE, Ch.FIN, Ch.EST, Ch.LVA, Ch.LTU, Ch.BALT, JCh.EST Almi Yurnis Vermont × RKF1532793 EST01495/05 |
||||
Dilina Royal Precious Simonetta EST 02736/03 |
|||||
JCh.RUS, Ch.RUS Gloria Victoribus × |
Olympus Uppercut Innay |
JCh. Starpom Zip Gun × RKF 3440659 |
Ch.RKF, Ch.RUS, Ch.CAN, Ch.USA Island’s Hanging With The Band × RKF3033000 AKC TR65580601 |
Ch.RUS, Ch.CAN, Ch.USA Cr Classic Act × AKCTR49660004 |
Ch.USA Cheyennes Kodiak Bear Second × AKC TP09565801 Eyes clear, LCP clear, hips excellent |
Geebears Cr Carebear AKC TR16074106 Eyes clear, hips good |
|||||
Ch.CAN Pominique Flecks Of Gold × AKCTR218 |
Ch.RKF, Ch.RUS, Ch.USA PJ’s Sir Richard Of Goldchip × AKC TR02232302 RKF1920226 |
||||
Pominique Black Hills Gold AKC TP27560201 |
|||||
Ac Dynasty Order To Communicate HKKC 56375 RKF2684851 |
Ch. Chriscendo Communicado × CKC NL891969 AKC TR25029102 |
Ch.CAN Peppipom’s Classically Yours × GS454361 |
|||
Chriscendo Cameo Rose CKC KG674331 |
|||||
Chriscendo Cabana HKKC 54734 CKC TL170878 |
Ch.CAN, Ch.USA, Ch.THA Starlight’s Dream Comes True × THKC 05111332 |
||||
Ch.CAN Chriscendo Cottage Rose × CKC PW003893 |
|||||
Saint Thais T’Emmy RKF2851915 |
Grand Ch.RUS, JCh.RUS, Ch.CLUB, Ch.RFOS, Ch.OANKOO, Ch.RFSS, Ch.RUS Bravo’s Traveling In Time × RKF2410414 AKC TR76421504 |
Ch. Mountain Crest Traveling Man × AKC TR432022/01 ISBR 354151 |
Ch.USA Paughprints On The Mtn Crest × AKC TN55922501 (11-98) |
||
Mountain Crest Sillie Millie AKC TR15451901 |
|||||
Aj’s Laralie RKF 3408431 AKC TR36431403 |
Ch.USA Aj’s Tuff As Nails × |
||||
Tabitha Of Lenette AKC TR15392101 |
|||||
Saint Thais Black Star Lady RKF2419307 |
JCh.RUS, Ch.RUS, Ch.CZE, Ch.BLR, Ch.UKR Beautiful Star’s Tracker × THKC E06111902RKF2005156 |
Golden Star’s Rocket Man THKC E05111020 |
|||
Beautiful Star’s Micky THKC R05110819 |
|||||
JCh. Ulysses × RKF 2074877 |
Grand Ch.RUS, Ch.RKF, Ch.INT, Ch.RUS, Ch.EST, Ch.YUG, Ch.LTU, Ch.GEO, Ch.LVA, Ch.BLR, JCh.LIT Aj’s High Impact × RKF1327184 AKC TP19779101 |
||||
Chanel Fragrance of Love RKF 1645581 |
|||||
Fabi Funny Doll RKF 3928639 |
Boy with a Finger from the Miracle Shop RKF24 |
JCh.RUS, Ch.RKF, Ch.OANKOO, Ch.RUS, Grand Ch.UKR, Ch.FIN, Ch.UKR, Ch.BLR Jan-Shar’s Crown Prince × RKF1868752 AKC TR46995102 |
Ch.USA Jan-Shar’s If Looks Could Kill × AKC TN86064401 |
Ch.USA Tradition’s Legend Of Oakridge × AKC TN1062053 |
|
Jan-Shar’s Lilly Of The Valley AKC TN60115404 |
|||||
Jan-Shar’s Mamma Mia AKC TP08 | 3 |
Ch. Tookeyes The Gold Smith × AKC TN26480801 |
|||
Jan-Shar’s Little Orphan Annie AKC TN02080102 |
|||||
Hermione of the Miracle Shop RKF 2434545 |
Finch’s Parti Dressed To Impress AKC TR51867303 |
Ch.USA Finch’s Parti To Impress Me × AKC TR26583101 |
|||
Finch’s Wild Party Tonight AKC TP29809301 |
|||||
Pom City Iris RKF 1992794 |
Ch.RKF, Ch.RUS, Ch.USA Jolvin’s Opaline Peannete Royale × RKF1639000 AKC TR 19421901 |
||||
Patricia Mini Bikini RKF1144241 |
|||||
Gemeni Beauty RKF2759144 |
JCh. Royal Poms Julius Caesar × RKF 2203024 |
Ch.RFLS, Ch.RUS, Ch.CAN Damascus Road Dream Of Tucson × RKF17 CKC PG944932 |
Ch.USA, Ch.CAN Chriscendo Call To Arms × CKC KJ674330 AKC TP16427301 |
||
Bavanew’s Gabby At Damascus Road CKC MS833370 |
|||||
Chikai Sushi RKF2057515 CKC PY 996730 |
Ch.CAN Chikai The First One I Love × CKC MC813306 |
||||
Chikai I’m Happy Princess CKC KW696012 |
|||||
Delight of the Soul Joy RKF 2258216 |
Ch.RFSS, Ch.RUS Tair Theme × RKF1843521 |
JCh. |